|
| ||||
|
New forum, please make sure you select which category you need to post in. Any posts just dropped in the general category will be moved or deleted, depending on what mood the moderators are in.
Page:
1
Mill Drill machinesMill Drill machinesI'm thinking of replacing my pillar drill with a mill drill machine. Can anyone advise me as to whether machines costing under £1000 are worth buying? I'm not envisaging doing any particularly heavy work, but would like something thats reasonably robust and can be accurately set up.
Administrator has disabled public posting
Re: Mill Drill machines When considering the bench mount types it's probably fair to say that the round column machines are best thought of as drill / mills leaving the dovetail column breed as mill / drills. Fundamental problem with the round column breed is that moving the head up and down without loss of angular registration is impossible in standard form with virtually all makes. The old Naerock machines had a registration key which I believe was quite accurate but generally you will need to devise your own or copy one of the many published methods if such registration is important. The big disadvantage is that you have to set-up so as to have both sufficient daylight between chuck, collet or end mill holder and work to handle tool changes yet be able to cover the depth of cut needed with the available quill travel. Depending on the size and type of work envisaged this varies from irritating to toys out of pram time. Its a great help if the job is small enough to crank out of the way when tool changing. Inevitably you end up working with a good deal of quill extension a lot of the time. Generally considered not ideal practice as it reduces rigidity whatever the machine and a small, economically priced home shop machine will be less rigid to start with. The dovetail column type does allow you to move the head up and down at will and tend to be more rigid so comparatively speaking its a win-win.
Administrator has disabled public posting
Re: Mill Drill machines I'm not saying that the mill/drill is no good, as I survived with one for many years., and that is what it is, pure survival. Just too many variables to attempt to do super accurate work.
Administrator has disabled public posting
Re: Mill Drill machines I have to agree with the guys above, a drill/mill is not a milling machine. I've been using one for ages, and until I get my second Haighton Mill finished it'll have to do any little milling jobs I need.
Bill
Administrator has disabled public posting
Page:
1
Board Info
Forum Legend:
Gallery |





















































